Each evening I look forward to the day’s recap with my kids.
They each have a chance to fill Mamma in on all the successes of the day and all
the things that may have gone awry, from stumbles, to a scolding, to disagreements
with friends. My boys are almost always
to the point and often require a bit of coaxing getting both the full story
along with what impact the incident actually had on them (physically and
emotionally). The reverse is true of my girl, Shiloh, who delivers her reports with a level of detail and
complexity that often leaves me feeling as though I’ve been called to jury duty
– It takes a well-tuned ‘Mamma-ear’ to filter though the (possible) facts of
the case in an effort to determine who the real criminal may be.
I arrived at the daycare and from a distance I notice that
she had a sizable patch under her right eye. My initial assumption was that
they were playing pirates or worriers and she was still in partial garb. The
daycare worker approached me with an incident report in hand that captured what
I thought was a clear-cut case. She
explained that the kids went to the park, Shiloh got excited, bolted ahead to
get to the slide and managed to run face first into a post resulting in a gash
on her bottom eye lid. The written report explained that the wound was cleaned
and bandaged and that the teacher had a short chat with her about running off;
Simple enough.I waited until we were home to ask my daughter for her account of the event. She threw her hands forward as if to command silence in the court and began “Well, first of all Mamma, none of the teachers were looking at me! NONE!” she emphasized, with her stubby index finger wagging around.
Are your Mamma-ears tuned? Do you see what she did there?
Before the facts are even delivered she paints a scenario where the responsibility, even in part, does not fall squarely on her shoulders. In law they call it reasonable doubt! What’s worse is I do have to give her credit for highlighting a valid point – was there sufficient supervision if she was able to bolt away from the pack?
She continued “I did want to get to the slide first so I ran ahead…”
I figured this was her confession of wrongdoing so I interjected, “And you weren’t paying attention and you ran into the post? You know you’re not supposed to run of like that.”
She shook her head and again put her hands up (order in the court) “No no Mamma, I saw the post and I was planning to duck under it but it was the boots Mamma, these boots!” she pointed downward with much exasperation to her bright pink winter gear. “The boots!? How did the boots make you run into the post?! They don’t move your legs little missy” I was certain that even at four years old she could see that this was not a valid argument…. And then she proved me wrong.
“Moooommmmm” with much frustration (as though this
juror was far too simple-minded to appreciate the intricacies of the case), “I
saw the post; I was going to duck; so my body stopped! It did… my arms stopped
and my legs stopped but with all that snow the boots just kept going and going
and then, boopsie I hit the post. AND
THAT is how I got this cut with all the blood. Did the teacher tell you I had a
lot of, lot of blood?”
A stellar closing argument; opening by bringing my attention
to the possibility of another party that should hold blame; giving the basics
truths of the story while simultaneously shifting the blame even further from
accused and then closing by again redirecting
my attention that third party and bringing their trustworthiness into
question (the teachers hadn’t mention
just how much blood there was).
The Jury finds the defendant GUILTY - of being too smart, witty and terribly loveable!
Love and Guidance
No comments:
Post a Comment