My parents, both raised in the Caribbean, describe a time when parenting was a community effort. A hard hand was often the quick response to disobedience and disrespectful behaviour. It was not uncommon for a whooping to be delivered by a neighbour, extended family or family friend and followed up by a further reprimand from parents for the reported infraction. Although I also grew up in the Caribbean, the communal touch on parenting had diminished slightly. I experienced only verbal scoldings from elders while corporal punishment was reserved for parents and school teachers. Now as a parent, drawing bits from those before me and making the alterations to fit my lifestyle, I chose a long time ago to be more creative in my response to non-compliance. I would never expect or condone a person outside of my home smacking my children and any bum-smacks that I deliver are specific to defiance that may cause physical harm.
I am not attempting to build an argument for spankings -I did get my fair share; I did turn out fine; still, I don't believe that it should be the first resort when correcting a child.
A few weeks ago Samuel caught me off-guard. He had been in an exceptionally foul mood the entire morning and 'No' was his choice word of the day. At the produce store I attempted to call him away from a gate that he kept tugging at while I was cashing out. First warning went un-heeded as did the second. I marched over and took him by the arm to move him away.The little rebel not only attempted the classic floppy-body manoeuvre but I managed to catch his little fist mid-swing!! My first thought was to drop his pants right there; after all, that was the go-too disciplinary tactic passed down to me precisely for circumstances like this! How dare he raise his hands to his mother! My eyes then darted up at the small audience - all pretending not to notice the conflict. I drop to my knee to face the tot eye to eye. In the back of my head I could see the headline roll out: "Immigrant mother Jailed for Public Spanking". I exhale..... How effective could it possibly be to teach a child not to hit by hitting him anyway?! Plus, the very thought of jail time was a sufficient antidote for my anger. Instead I firmly draw him close and made him look me in the eye forcing him to speak up - to explain exactly what he thought he was going to do!
Seems the kid may be a quick study because the apology rolled out without any further prompting.
This week however I caught a video being circulated on social media that made me question my choices on that day. The baseline of the drama was identical: Mother attempting to correct her son in a store. The difference in this footage was that this boy was older (at least a pre-teen) and the 'floppy-body' was replaced with profanity spewed by the child; the mother followed suit, descending to a base choice of words; she proceeded to take the first swing and the child answered with a swift overarm fist. A 'good-Samaritan' intervened and attempted to restrain the mother as the boy continued to take jabs at her. At one point toward the end, with agony in her voice, she yells, "I just can't take these damned kids any more!"
My questions and thoughts:
- How do things go that tragically wrong with parenting?
- Why was the mother being restrained as she attempted to discipline her out-of-control son?
- Why didn't a single bystander, (camera-man included) try pulling the child away?
- If the kid continues along that path, he may be a prime candidate for the prison systems.
- I think he got passed over on some lickings when he was younger... WAIT....
- Did I give Samuel a pass?
- How am I to be certain that my child learned the lesson?
- *Holds head in panic* Is Samuel a ticking social media video waiting to explode?!!
I can speculate that there is a much deeper, unfortunate back-story for the pair caught on camera that led to that moment; and can only hope that the home that my husband and I have created gives our children an advantage. Though the future holds no guarantees, for now I must believe that our choices as parents will protect them from such an outcome; I must accept that parenting is a learning process; I must hold faith that my children will one day appreciate the boundaries set and the lines of respect established in our family regardless of the era or our social setting. I have a long road ahead....my continuous prayer is for guidance.

Great insight Tanes, clearly every day is a learning experience as a parent. You're right by saying that corporal punishment should not be the 'go to' method for discipline and I do think Sammy who can still be considered a toddler lashing out is still an unconscious act of rebellion. I'm sure if the same instance occurred with Josiah you'd be quicker to execute swift and precise punishment that would deter even the thought to attempt such an act again. I truly believe that in all things love is the answer and even spankings given in love and overstanding will be accepted at some point in life. Blessings!
ReplyDeleteExactly Q, It is scary... I think my parents are fabulous and still the children of our age are a lot different than I was, the social structure has changed, lifestyles have changed thus the 'tricks' in parenting must be adjusted.
DeleteThe constant however is the 'intent'... our ever action as a parent should be with the aim of raising a child that knows that they are loved, knows that they are special and understands that boundaries are required so that they can maximize their potential.. Love must lead.
That's my constant fear/worry as well. Well said,- except for foul ;-) sorry I just had to! lol
ReplyDeleteEEEEK!! Thanks Stacy!! That's what happens when you try to finish editing 20 mins before getting ready for work!!! LOL Corrected now! :-)
DeleteA friend of mine had the unfortunate experience whilst on a trip to the Caribbean... Whilst on board the flight, her 5 year old kid decided to do a "walk about" the aircraft, obviously to the inconvenience to the other passengers. My friend tried every politically correct persuasion, without success to have the kid return to his seat so she decided to use some stern Caribbean tactics.... Wrong move! The kid started screaming, " Help me! I have been kidnapped! I don't know this lady!" To make a long story short, my friend on disembarking the aircraft was pulled aside and questioned by authorities. How do you handle that?
ReplyDeleteThat is a whole other ball game.. when it comes to correcting OTHER people's children. I've taken the chance and scolded kids before. But as I pointed out in the article above the communal touch to parenting is fading. We are now in a time where folks are offended if you even verbally redirect a child. It is discouraging as a parent.
DeleteInteresting read! I think that with the other parent/pre teen situation, the child is simply sprouting the fruit that was sown (cussing and hitting). I am sure that there was a lot more behind closed doors and what you saw in public was just the symptom of a deeper issue.
ReplyDeleteI think you that as long as one strives for an authentic relationship, with natural consequences, in love, you will be fine. You're one of the best moms I know, so I think you're doing the right thing :)